Why Cuddli, a dating app for geeks, failed

Why Cuddli, a dating app for geeks, failed

Hello Robert! What’s your background, and what are you now engaged on?

I spent 13 years at Microsoft, working my plan up from a technical creator to eventually working IT for, and reporting to the pinnacle of, Microsoft Overview Asia whereas residing and dealing in Beijing.

When it was once time to depart Beijing, I made up my choices to depart Microsoft and streak for a world MBA in The Netherlands. For part of this method, I used to be an commerce pupil at INCAE in Costa Rica the impact I took a category in entrepreneurship and mission capital. Proper all through the route of that class, I bought in level of reality excited by the prospect of leveraging my software skills right into a startup, and the plans for Cuddli began to fetch form. I labored on Cuddli with the crew besides the cease of 2018. We have been faulty bootstrappers and saved Cuddli alive by sheer stress of will, but it surely by no means realized a reliable ample market.

Cuddli's logo

I at present work as a senior information security architect for the Say of Washington. Because it seems to be, I discovered lots about security defending prospects of our app worthy. Nonetheless, this was once a restricted time gig, it’s wrapping up, and the monetary system has it appears right collapsed amid a Coronavirus pandemic. I in level of reality possess my subsequent position lined up after this (in idea), however inquire of of me yet again in just a few months whether or not it panned out or whether or not I’m even silent alive. Additionally, if the airline business ever turns into operational yet again (as I write this, international air net expose on-line guests is heading towards a fleshy flooring halt), I assist other people information journeys with their miles and substances at my agency AwardCat.

What motivated you to beginning up Cuddli?

I wasn’t single as quickly as I moved to The Netherlands to beginning up my MBA, however the relationship ended rapidly after I relocated to Europe. I began utilizing relationship apps and the consumer journey was once (and stays) extremely irritating. The first enterprise mannequin of freemium relationship apps (which is the overwhelming majority of the market) is to introduce friction and label prospects to fetch away it. This mainly locations the core ardour of shoppers (assembly other people) at odds with the connection app’s enterprise mannequin.

I believed there was once the following gadget to invent a relationship app and began from a enterprise viewpoint on the order (by the way, this sounds logical however was once a traditional error). What if a relationship app, in its very compose, had aligned pursuits with the shoppers? That was once the standard principle in beginning Cuddli: it began with a enterprise thought (which I silent deem is a correct one) and labored backward from that into discovering a market, as a various of beginning with a motivated neighborhood of shoppers and discovering a workable enterprise mannequin from there.

Cuddli app UX

I additionally sought suggestions from retailers. They raised all kinds of (neatly-behaved) issues with relationship apps, much like the viewers repeatedly altering, consumer churn (other people had no objective to proceed utilizing an app after they met), and loads of others. We solved for practically all of those within the app compose.

How did you invent it?

I went to streak to my buddy Steve in Croatia. We each grew up within the Seattle dwelling however he fell in fancy with a Croatian lady and ended up transferring there. We have been speaking about my relationship frustrations, the enterprise thought, and the explosive improve of Tinder and we decided that we have been going to invent this half.

Excessive-notch cell app builders have been sensible in Croatia, Steve is a developer himself and he would perhaps perhaps write the help cease server code, and our mutual buddy Pinguino joined because the third co-founder two weeks later (she’s an superb clothier and because it seems to be, additionally mainly essentially the most attention-grabbing boss I in level of reality possess ever labored for).

I began as CEO and later grew to become COO, and took care of the enterprise side of points.

From Wall Aspect road to Silicon Valley…

Are you busy? Apparent you’re — that is why you want to Morning Brew. Or not it’s a free day-to-day piece of email that provides a transient 5-minute rundown of the day’s prime enterprise information. Be a part of the 925,000+ these that beginning up their day with Morning Brew!

👉 Learn Extra!

We’re publishing interviews like this one all weeks. Put up your piece of email if you happen to happen to wish to fetch them in your inbox + net 80+ offers on instruments to will allow you to scale your startup (worth as lots as $50,000)!

Your subscription would perhaps perhaps now not be saved. Please strive yet again.

Your subscription has been pleasurable.

Which have been your advertising and marketing ideas to develop your enterprise?

We thought the app would promote itself. It was once filled with superb features that no different relationship app had (there was once no friction for purchasers in any respect, every and every attribute of the app was once accessible for unpaid prospects), the compose was once phenomenal, and we threw a in level of reality reliable originate celebration in LA. We launched on Android first, since that had 90% of the cell market on the time (all individuals else was once launching on iOS). We had, on a punch itemizing, addressed every and every order retailers will potential be able to possess concerning the sustainability of the enterprise mannequin. We actually thought that the app was once so neatly designed, so accessible, and eradicated so highly effective friction that it could perhaps perhaps naturally fetch off. Our first indication that we’d made a in level of reality superb mistake by launching on Android is when every and every single tech blogger and reporter who confirmed up at our originate celebration had an iPhone.

Cuddli's app venues

Minute did everyone knows on the time that it’s in level of reality exhausting to develop the viewers for a relationship app. Earned media is nearly very important, and I in level of reality blew it by deciding to originate on Android. This was once an absolutely extreme error, and we’d possess saved ourselves some big money and time by right shutting down then. 

Most relationship apps are segmentation performs, and there may be easiest room for just a few market leaders who can fetch assist of a abilities shift. Sadly, Grindr, Tinder, and Bumble had been first to market on cell and had captured the overwhelming majority of big-based largely audiences. All that was once in level of reality left have been segmentation performs.

We additionally like a flash came upon that we had nearly nothing on the entire with mainstream audiences, so couldn’t compose relatable advertising and marketing collateral for these audiences on our possess. We’re all geeks, so what we did that eventually labored was once to revert to our genuine selves. We tweaked the app to state to geeks like us, and we began selling the app specifically particular person to geek audiences at geek occasions like amusing-cons and anime conferences. This truly resonated–we have been a relationship app by and for geeks. We began to net earned media safety, grew to become one among the halt relationship apps in Spain (for some objective, the app wasn’t in Spanish and we had by no means performed any advertising and marketing there), and we truly created the category of geek relationship apps, turning into the #1 app within the class.

Cuddli events

Of us most in pattern our app so highly effective that they requested us how they will assist. We spoke again by sending them “Ambassador Packs” with a Cuddli T-shirt, flyers and stickers which they will distribute at their favorite geek spots to aid Cuddli develop. Sure, prospects most in pattern our app so highly effective that they have been truly doing work with out value to aid us develop. I’d like to assert that our advertising and marketing was once deliberate brilliance however we truly right made points up as we went alongside and doubled down on the whole thing we realized that was once working.

Sadly, it wasn’t a reliable ample class, which I’ll net to within the subsequent fragment.

Which have been the causes of Cuddli failure?

Most startups fail due to founder infighting, understanding of mission capital, or a failure to net product-market match. We constructed Cuddli ourselves, and by no means took beginning up air funding. All of us stay correct mates and possess labored on different initiatives collectively. And we had an fabulous product-market match: we have been the #1 app in our class, with over 100,000 prospects and growing a whole bunch of fantastically geeky “Cuddli {couples}.” 

So why did we cease, after 4 lengthy, exhausting years of creating a class-main app (and after I invested my full life’s monetary financial savings)? We merely had no path to profitability or to exit, and we have been all out of personal runway. We knew that we might possess most in pattern to each promote or shut the app.

Our core concept for monetization was once clever, however extremely onerous to realize as a result of we have been right too early. We constructed-in Foursquare into the app and constructed a date scheduler. As a result of we might perhaps perhaps tag that our prospects visited a bodily location, we thought eating places, bars, and different date spots could be excited to confederate with us. The reception was once lukewarm at best – these are companies that function on razor-thin margins so selling to them is hard, and getting paid is much more tough. If I wanted to finish this over yet again, I’d confederate with Airbnb and promote their experiences as date experiences (this wasn’t an choice since Airbnb initially launched “Experiences” rapidly sooner than we shut down).

We additionally bought customized digital stickers within the app, alongside the strains of LINE. We spent weeks and a whole bunch of greenbacks constructing the performance to finish so, and I deem we easiest ever bought Three of them.  

Within the cease, after we have been taking a seek for to promote the app itself, nobody desired to grasp it apart from spammers who would cease hideous, unethical points with it. We have been strongly values-driven (to the purpose that our values have been on our entrance web page), and impact our cash the impact our mouths have been, refusing to promote to any person who wouldn’t uphold them. We eventually closed the app.

Which have been your most attention-grabbing errors and challenges you wanted to beat?

My most attention-grabbing errors have been (a) constructing the app in accordance with a enterprise mannequin as a various of an viewers, (b) making a strategic error on the originate platform that label us terribly treasured earned media, and (c) being the rotten CEO for the agency.

I already addressed (a) and (b) above, however being the rotten CEO for the agency was once very important studying. One half that I deem we did right is to invent the agency on a basis of values and inspire ourselves responsible to them. These have been ours:

  • The full lot we cease begins and ends with other people.
  • We always focus on our prospects first.
  • We’re all crew avid players.
  • We’re humble and self-excessive.
  • We discuss overtly and really.
  • We clear up issues, now not compose them.
  • We articulate on our guarantees.

Following the values of talking overtly and really and fixing issues, now not growing them, we’d possess very deep conversations. Endure in choices that Pinguino, Steve, and I in level of reality possess all recognized one however one other for over 15 years, and we have been all correct mates sooner than we began Cuddli, so we have been uniquely positioned to finish this. Nevertheless we have been additionally all older, and I deem this helped a lot–we have been extra worn.

There was once some extent within the agency the impact it grew to become evident that my advertising and marketing initiatives have been gaining restricted traction, Pinguino’s consumer acquisition initiatives have been gaining in level of reality intensive traction, and mainly essentially the most attention-grabbing half our agency vital to finish was once net prospects, now not cease MBA stuff with enterprise units. I stepped apart as CEO and moved right into a supporting position as COO and chairman of the board. Pinguino stepped up as CEO, and the reality that she did saved the agency alive for however one other two years.

Which have been your costs? Did you cease some income? Within the cease, how highly effective cash did you lose?

We have been faulty bootstrappers. To invent the app and bustle it for four years, together with all software sample costs, advertising and marketing costs, webhosting costs, firm submitting (in two worldwide areas), and loads of others. label just a little decrease than $200,000. Proper right here is as a result of we did the entire work ourselves, somewhat than coding the cell apps (the server code was once written by Steve, and in parallel, he labored with builders in Croatia who constructed the cell apps in accordance with Pinguino’s compose). 

Nevertheless at what personal expenses? I lived in a neighborhood so harmful my neighbor was once murdered. I used to be so sad that I licensed for Medicaid. I began to note at areas beneath bridges and began severely pondering “if I lived in a tent beneath there, I might perhaps perhaps prolong my runway.” Pinguino’s relationship alongside along with her confederate grew to become strained from lack of earnings. Steve lived in a Soviet-generation constructing the effect–I specific I’m now not making this up–raw sewage was once pouring from the ceiling correct by one go to. All of us stretched ourselves to the restrict–and then some–protecting the app afloat by sheer grit and dedication if now not outright lunacy.

The app by no means made cash and we misplaced the whole thing we invested.

Everytime you wanted to beginning up over, what would you cease in every other case?

It seems to be painfully evident now, however there are two points that I could now not cease as an entrepreneur going forward.

  • I obtained’t impact in my possess cash. OK, I’ve broken this rule with AwardCat however that was once a in level of reality low cost enterprise to invent. It label me decrease than $3,000 in coding utilizing a reliable crew in Ukraine (I labored with them onsite in Kyiv), and it has made significantly higher than that. If I have been constructing a loopy extreme chance, mission-scale startup yet again, I’d elevate mission capital or streak dwelling. Finishing up retailers unfold chance throughout a portfolio however founders easiest possess one startup.
  • I’ll receives a fee. Essentially, I need a relate to dwell, ample to eat, and medical insurance coverage. I’ll net a tech job with roughly zero dangers so if I beginning up a startup, my “pores and skin within the sport” is the reality that I’m working extra hours and making much less cash than however one other job. Residing beneath a bridge (even though fortunately it by no means acquired proper right here to that for me) is a truly massive distraction and startups require your fleshy consideration.

Which are your favorite entrepreneurial assets?

I deem mainly essentially the most attention-grabbing other people to be taught from are different founders, at founder occasions. As an illustration, WeAreLATech has an “journey membership” the impact LA dwelling founders can advance collectively and enjoy an train much like an net away room, but additionally possess conversations with these that might perhaps perhaps uniquely state.

Produce specific to net to know founders at different phases, now not easiest early-stage founders. Later stage founders “pay it forward” lots they usually additionally’re going to even be priceless sources of information; right endure in choices that they’re busier than you.

One of many very important least treasured sources of information are mission capitalists. They’re sharks–they’re natty, however additionally they possess entertaining tooth. One tall mistake I made was once listening too highly effective to the opinions of VCs and now not (a minimal of initially) discovering these that might perhaps perhaps perhaps even be potential prospects and speaking to them. VCs expose they care about profitability and enterprise units, however what they in fact care about is the market dimension and exponential improve. They’re looking to hit as shut to the underside of a hockey stick in improve as that you just would perhaps perhaps be able to take heed to. They write and focus on what they’re looking to publicly sign they’re investing in, however a variety of their suggestion easiest sounds correct with the help of hindsight. Additionally, VCs who would by no means in level of reality make investments in your enterprise will silent kick the tires and lunge all kinds of holes in it. These holes will potential be each totally neatly-behaved and in addition now not even shut to mainly essentially the most attention-grabbing half to give attention to. Some would perhaps even give you suggestion that is borderline unethical.

Tag that VCs who possess invested in your agency or who’re personal mates are a wholly different breed. You’re part of their portfolio (or social circle) then, and your pursuits are (a minimal of significantly) aligned. An unaligned VC’s weblog is an attention-grabbing information level however steadily no higher than that.

I deem that many tech entrepreneurs “pooh-pooh” enterprise assets within the neighborhood which might perhaps be reliable treasured. I educate a category on startups and entrepreneurship at a neighborhood college, which is educated by the very staunch experiences we had. You may net a feeble founder instructing a the identical class at your area people college. The SBA hosts workshops for potential entrepreneurs. Proper here is a reliable gadget to satisfy different founders who you obtained’t be competing with and would perhaps even collaborate with. It’s additionally very highly effective worth going to pitch competitions (right here’s our pitch deck, btw) to survey what different startups are out there, and what retailers are at present most interested in funding (this isn’t to assert that you just must silent depart tendencies, easiest to net intelligence).

The impact will we streak to be taught extra?

Right here’s my modern agency, Award Cat. I additionally bustle a commute weblog, which you’d perhaps perhaps be able to web right here.

You must silent additionally give a learn to my article: “Is your unicorn in point of truth a shark?”.

✉️ Subscribe to our e-newsletter!

Invite us into your inbox and net big studying and 80+ offers on instruments to will allow you to scale your startup (worth as lots as $50,000)!

Your subscription would perhaps perhaps now not be saved. Please strive yet again.

Your subscription has been pleasurable.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here